I've been trying to use various apps but with my studies and work schedule being so demanding I have a hard time justifying a monthly subscription. Wenzhou dialect ranked first, followed by Cantonese. 16 tonals,its like singing a frickin song! The language of Mandarin is easier to learn than that of Cantonese because Mandarin has only four tones, whereas Cantonese has six to nine tones. Cantonese requires speakers to recognize the tone by the movement of sound as well as the pitch. Cantonese is spoken in mainland China as a lingua franca in areas in and around the Guangdong Province . 114 12. But you should still know that Cantonese is often seen as more difficult. Not only is it a great exercise for the brain, but it'll open up a world of opportunity for you - from the ability to communicate with and befriend over 1 billion people to expanding your business network and . When should I start to learn Chinese characters? Mandarin is easy for Cantonese speakers to master but the same cannot be said for Mandarin speakers trying to learn Cantonese - they will find it difficult to speak to someone who speaks in Cantonese. On the other hand, no Mandarin tone maps directly to a Cantonese tone. (I am slowly learning Mandarin myself and man is the pronunciation hard. Mandarin is the official language in China, foreigners think it is difficult to learn, while there are actually many Chinese dialects are much harder than learning Mandarin! 2. To learn Cantonese or Mandarin definitely depends on your personal choice and your reasons for learning, e.g. Mandarin Vs. Cantonese, it's all Chinese, but which one should I learn?Check out the following video to see how Mandarin Vs. Cantonese is different from each. Learning Cantonese with Online Courses. A Mandarin speaker would read these out as wǒ, shān, and shuǐ, while in Cantonese they're ngóh, sāan, and sēoi. Secondly, Cantonese does not have standardised romanisation as Mandarin does, so it can often be difficult to get the meaning of new words you hear if you can't pronounce them properly. It's helped me pick up Mandarin and learn faster. 116 15. 2. In this video I ask a couple folks on the street in Yangshuo what they think, t. There are two main reasons why Cantonese is even harder than Mandarin: 1. Thus, most Cantonese speakers can understand Mandarin, but not many Mandarin speakers know . Are there some budget ways to learn Cantonese? Many people believe that learning Cantonese is harder than learning Mandarin because of its complex tone system. Many say it is far more difficult to learn Cantonese than Mandarin because the former . This alone makes learning Cantonese worthwhile. Once you understand this, regardless of whether you learn Cantonese or Mandarin, your learning will accelerate. I (informally) taught a handful of native Mandarin speakers how to speak Cantonese, and the first and most impactful resource is this table: You can also compare and contrast. And Cantonese speakers are increasingly learning Mandarin to find work in Mainland China. The complex writing system. Which Chinese Language To Learn Mandarin Or Cantonese? A netizen once posted a ranking of the "Top Ten Most Difficult Dialects in China". You can learn Mandarin Chinese That's nonsense of course. Learning Chinese opens the door to a thousand years of Chinese culture that has impacted cultures all over Asia. Jade is able to provide thorough, easily understood explanations of difficult grammatical concepts and concrete, real-world examples from Cantonese's vast vocabulary. Cantonese has six to nine tones whereas Mandarin has four tones. Through this Mandarin course, I learned the idea of leveraging Cantonese to learn Mandarin and it has helped me pick up Mandarin easier. Naturally, if you're aiming for a very high level, it will take time, but I have met many learners who have studied for just a few months (albeit very diligently), and have been able to converse rather freely in Mandarin after that time. They can understand it somewhat, but do not speak it. Free 127-page 'The Complete Guide To Learn Cantonese" PDF for download ( perfect for beginners to get a grasp of what it takes to learn Cantonese). I am white and my wife and in-laws are Chinese-American; the in-laws speak Cantonese and Mandarin, but their English is a bit broken and hard to understand (My wife's English is perfectly fine). The Chinese writing system is one of the more challenging aspects of learning Chinese. As we covered above, Mandarin is easier to learn in regards to both writing and speaking. Can Mandarin speakers understand Cantonese? In our view, it's about time we stop asking "is it hard to learn Mandarin Chinese" and instead just start learning. Cantonese has more tones than Mandarin, but Mandarin has a few sounds Cantonese doesn't. The sounds are easy to learn though. Growing up, I always believed that Chinese is the toughest language to learn. Therefore, there is no real need to learn Cantonese if you are visiting Hong Kong for work. Mandarin is easier to learn. 113 11. As someone who has tried learning Mandarin through youtube videos, apps, and private classes, Mandarin was really hard to pick up. People tend to find Cantonese difficult because it is a tonal language. If you really want to be able to connect with people from Hong Kong, Macau, and Canton, you can still consider learning Cantonese. So it seems as though Mandarin is more practical than Cantonese. Top 5 reasons why Chinese is hard to learn. I can only speak the cantonese language and a few sentences of mandarin. But you can overcome this! My Taishanese and Cantonese speaking parents are in their 70s and came to Canada separately as young adults. Learning Cantonese is even harder. Cantonese is by far the more challenging of the two languages, particularly for a beginning Chinese language learner. While most words in Cantonese have one syllable, Mandarin frequently has words with three or more syllables. Lack of learning resources in Cantonese. Is Learn to Speak Cantonese 1 by Jade Jiu Ying Wu a good place for me to start as a beginner? Fujian dialect was only selected . 10. So it's clear that Cantonese pronunciation is different from Mandarin. That's not to say that learning Cantonese is a waste of time, and for some people, it may be the better choice, but for most people wanting to speak "Chinese", Mandarin is the way to go. How hard is learning Cantonese? Top Learning Mandarin is easy for Cantonese speakers and vice-versa. Cantonese also doesn't have an official writing system, rather Cantonese speakers normally read and write in Standard Chinese, which uses Mandarin vocabulary and grammar, and then have a separate writing system they use to represent colloquial speech. My favourite way to learn a language is by doing full immersion in the place where the language is spoken by natives. These tones are vital when trying to convey your meaning, making Cantonese harder to learn than Mandarin. Mandarin is easier to learn Cantonese is seen to be more difficult because it has from 6 to 9 tones, each of which signify different things (while Mandarin only has 4 tones). Report Abuse 9 years 51 weeks ago. Be glad you aint in Nam etc. In addition, because of its greater prevalence, it is easier to find Mandarin study materials than Cantonese study materials. When I compare the both languages I think cantonese is more difficult. In addition, because of its greater prevalence, it is easier to find Mandarin study materials than Cantonese study materials. In fact, Mandarin is now an important business language for adults and the usage of Mandarin has been introduced to public service announcements in Hong Kong. So it's not the number of tones that makes Cantonese harder to learn, it's the fact that the tones in Cantonese are much harder to distinguish that makes it harder to learn. Should I learn Cantonese? But, it's still possible and something you should try if you are interested in the language! Many friends of mine from other places told me that Cantonese is too damn difficult to learn. The difference between Mandarin and Cantonese is that Mandarin has less tones and is used in the mainland. In learning, everyone has their difficulties and should apply all their effort on figuring out how they learn and work with that. 1. The biggest obstacle is learning a hosts of Cantonese-specific characters, as well as unfamiliar usages of characters you already know from Mandarin. 10.13 13. Cantonese is seen to be more difficult because it has from 6 to 9 tones, each of which signify different things (while Mandarin only has 4 tones). So it seems as though Mandarin is more practical than Cantonese. It is also said that you need to memorize at least 4000 Chinese characters if you want to read a newspaper. Local people in certain areas tend to learn Cantonese naturally through exposure to their parents, whereas Mandarin is generally taught in schools, and only learned at home at an early age when . Truth be told, Cantonese is not the easiest language to learn due to the many tones, for many people difficult pronunciation, and characters. In terms of learning difficulty, Burmese is an easier option for English speakers to learn than either Mandarin or Cantonese. However, we need to stress that these are simply not the same at all. Your first option is to learn Cantonese by attending online classes. The language is easier to learn in Mandarin than English As we discussed above, the language is easier to learn in both writing and speaking. And Cantonese speakers are increasingly learning Mandarin to find work in Mainland China. When you are learning Romance languages like Italian, French, or Spanish, learning to read and write is pretty straightforward. Now I've made a lot of progress, most of which has been because of more effective self study. Cantonese has only six tones while Mandarin has five. Guangdong language (Cantonese) has 8 (or 9 tonals depending on which A hole you talk to), So its more difficult for a westerner. 10.16 16. Continue such a project for a year and you will probably reach what most people would call fluent. Due to its greater prevalence, Mandarin study materials are easier to find than Cantonese study materials, as well. 115 13. And when you finally find one that looks perfect, you can't buy it locally. Mandarin became a subject in many primary schools beginning in 1998. Due to the fact that Cantonese has between six and nine tones, each representing a different thing (while Mandarin only has four tones), it is thought to be more difficult. Do you struggle to find bilingual books with Traditional Cantonese characters? If you've already learned to read Mandarin, then learning to read Cantonese can feel like playing the slightly more difficult sequel to a video game you put in hours trying to beat. What you find difficult may come easy to others and vice versa. As Group 5 languages, Mandarin Chinese and Cantonese Chinese need a good 2200 hours of study to properly learn. Why is Cantonese Even More Difficult Than Mandarin - Here are the reasons. The language of Mandarin is easier to learn than that of Cantonese because Mandarin has only four tones, whereas Cantonese has six to nine tones. Foreigners are suggested to learn Mandarin first. I personally think that it isn't that Chinese ITSELF is hard: it's the culture and custom that comes with it that makes Mandarin, Cantonese and all other Sinitic languages that makes any learner have to face the learning of this language with a healthy dose of humor and open-mindedness. The language is used in everyday life . Are there some budget ways to learn Cantonese? Answer (1 of 13): Native or not, knowing Mandarin is an asset. Cantonese (sometimes called standard Cantonese) has its origins in the area of Guangzhou (once called Canton) in the south of China. Along with Mandarin, Cantonese is also spoken throughout China and is an extremely useful (but difficult) language to learn. Read more. So many of the bilingual books out there are written for Mandarin speakers, or assume you can read and write fluently-and . Even if you don't know how to read or write Chinese, and speak only a liiiiitle bit of Cantonese, you still have a big advantage when it comes to learning Mandarin. Weicong Liang, Chinese Instructor and Teaching Supervisor at the Business Confucius Institute, University of Leeds, demystifies. This means you can learn CONVERSATIONAL Mandarin in just 6 weeks. My native language is Vietnamese, 2nd is English and 3rd is Mandarin. Should I learn Cantonese or Mandarin? If you're looking for ways you can use Cantonese to learn Mandarin, one is learning how Cantonese and Mandarin tones are related. Wenzhou dialect ranked first, followed by Cantonese. Even more so if staying in the region where it is spoken. Can Mandarin speakers understand Cantonese? While Cantonese may not be as widely spoken as Mandarin, it does have its uses. Songs in Cantonese are very popular in China, even though most people like songs in Cantonese actually do not speak Cantonese. Mainland China = Mandarin. Mandarin is much more widely spoken. A note to Cantonese learners. Should I take classes to learn Cantonese? These two things broke the ice for me. The difference between Mandarin and Cantonese number of tones contributes to the level of difficulty in speaking Chinese. A netizen once posted a ranking of the "Top Ten Most Difficult Dialects in China". If you're looking for ways you can use Cantonese to learn Mandarin, one is learning how Cantonese and Mandarin tones are related. Do children in Hong Kong learn . As I'm interested in it. Due to its greater prevalence, Mandarin study materials are easier to find than Cantonese study materials, as well. My wife is currently pregnant and we want our child to speak English, Cantonese, and other languages. Should I learn Cantonese? Now I've made a lot of progress, most of which has been because of more effective self study. Its use of "tones" can be even more challenging to western speakers than Mandarin. Sep 12, 2008 9:35 AM Sure, there are a few new sounds and symbols to add to . It is also spoken in Thailand, Malaysia, and Vietnam. 115 14. The Tones Mandarin has five tones, while Cantonese has nine different tones. Is it hard to learn Mandarin? Mandarin is the official language in China, foreigners think it is difficult to learn, while there are actually many Chinese dialects are much harder than learning Mandarin! 3. 117 Most responses and comments described learning the Mandarin Chinese script as extremely difficult. 10 Facts About Mandarin Chinese: Tones, Script and Dialects. Many consider Cantonese the prestige dialect of Yue. Cantonese is used in Hong Kong and southern areas. To die-hard Cantonese, no fans of the Communist government, this is one more reason to look down on Mandarin.

Rachmaninoff Prelude In C-sharp Minor Sheet Music Imslp, Cultured Vegan Cream Cheese Recipe, Bank Reconciliation Statement Is A Part Of, Macy's Sale Today Kitchen Appliances, Franklin The Turtle Snail Crying, Where Was Kyra Cooney Cross Born,